Amid a whirl of chatter last year about Elon Musk‘s acquisition of Twitter, a hazy vision began to materialize. Musk articulated his aspiration to mold Twitter into “X,” an “everything app.” An audacious notion that led many to draw parallels with China’s omnipotent WeChat, operated by the colossal Tencent. Today, as Twitter’s iconic bird logo morphs into an “X,” Elon Musk’s intention is more relevant than ever.
Musk’s ambition was clear from the start; he sought to evolve the platform beyond the bounds of traditional social media. “In the months to come, we will add comprehensive communications and the ability to conduct your entire financial world,” Musk declared, underscoring the fact that Twitter’s purchase was a strategic step towards realizing the ‘everything app’ or “Super App” dream.
According to Linda Yaccarino, the newly appointed CEO of the company, “X is the future state of unlimited interactivity – centered in audio, video, messaging, payments/banking – creating a global marketplace for ideas, goods, services, and opportunities.” This grand vision closely mirrors the concept of the “Super App,” a term coined and pioneered in China, and gradually gaining traction in other parts of Asia.
A Super App essentially serves as a digital Swiss army knife. These apps integrate diverse functions such as social media, payments, hotel and flight bookings, and taxi hailing, all under a single umbrella. WeChat, with its colossal user base of over 1.3 billion, stands as the prime example of a Super App. Users can instant message, make payments, access e-commerce and banking services, and more, all without leaving the app.
Last year, Musk lauded WeChat’s functionality, emphasizing the absence of its equivalent outside of China. “You basically live on WeChat in China because it’s so useful and so helpful to your daily life. And I think if we could achieve that, or even close to that with Twitter, it would be an immense success,” Musk opined. However, can such a Super App model gain similar traction outside of Asia?
WeChat’s success hinges on China’s unique internet landscape, largely shaped by the government’s stringent control over foreign online services like Twitter and Google. This control opened avenues for homegrown tech giants, like Tencent, to create a massive digital ecosystem. With its wide range of integrated services and ability for developers to create ‘mini programs’ within the app, WeChat serves as a one-stop digital solution for most users.
Despite the success of the Super App model in Asia, executing a similar metamorphosis in the U.S. or Europe might pose a Herculean challenge. The online payment landscape, a critical component of Super Apps, remains fragmented in the West with no dominant player. Traditional debit and credit card systems still hold sway, contrasting sharply with the QR code-based payments prevalent in China.
Moreover, sectors like ride-hailing and food delivery witness stiff competition in these regions, a fact that could potentially hamper the integration of such services into “X.” Coupled with these hurdles are potential complications concerning advertising competition and data ownership, particularly if “X” forges collaborations with other firms.
However, within these challenges lies an opportunity. Musk envisions “X” as a communication tool, not just a platform for short posts. The recent expansion of character limits for Twitter Blue subscribers could be an initial step in this direction. This move could potentially increase user engagement, paving the way for the addition of other services like payments.
As intriguing as Musk’s vision of Twitter transforming into a Super App may be, emulating the success of WeChat could prove to be a mammoth task. The conditions that facilitated WeChat’s ascent, such as China’s mobile-first market and a smaller pool of internet players, are notably absent in the U.S. and Europe. Regardless, the vision for “X” poses a bold and exciting step towards a more interconnected digital world. Let’s watch this space!
Click on this link to read this article in French version